| Year | Russell Scholarship | Garvin Scholarship | Heffron Scholarship | Foster Family Scholarship |
| 2024 | Maggie LeCroy | Grant Pagatpatan | Marlie Punch | Ally Jones |
| 2023 | Connor Donley | Somers Kirk | Poojith Reddy | Valeria Santiago |
| 2022 | Zana Norton | Lily Zimmerman | Joseph Truluck | Richard Hewitt |
| 2021 | Adams Keefer | Mary Cage Carter | Stephen Orr | Emma Templeton |
| 2020 | Abigail Green | Rebecca Liu | William Truluck | Elise Zimmerman |
| 2019 | Rebecca Spratt | Sullivan Long | Katelyn Schmedeke | Joshua Wallen |
| 2018 | Jared Pratt | Noah Johnson | Brendan Healey | Elizabeth Jones |
| 2017 | Cathy Chi | Trina Pham | Gracie Waldron | Alison Walsh |
| 2016 | Cross Tolliver | Jordan Paul | Katie Thompson | Brandon Ratterree |
| 2015 | Rachel Berkey | Caroline Sloop | Anna Maria Gardiner | |
| 2014 | Austin Heinz | Natalie Ivey | Parks Schoen | |
| 2013 | Logan Danzell | Bailey Shealy | Frederic Blais | |
| 2012 | Sarah McDonald | Ben Horst | Mareli Sanchez Julia | |
| 2011 | Thomas Lydon Jr. | Walker Heffron | Jennifer Anderson | |
| 2010 | Randall Heffron | Connor Evins | Christopher Suggs | |
| 2009 | Hagan Edgerton | Ross Fuller | Bobby Browning | |
| 2008 | Emily Black | Hannah Bruch | Nate Lyles | |
| 2007 | Elizabeth Appley | Luke Whiteside | Ashly Mitchell | |
| 2006 | Caleb Barnes | David Warren | Ben Taylor | |
| 2005 | Lee Floyd | Dana Richards | Daniel Knause | |
| 2004 | Sara Moyer | Thomas Stoddard | ||
| 2003 | Ryan Cook | Lauren Brown | ||
| 2002 | Moutray McLauren | Tara Hartness | ||
| 2001 | Allen Simmons | Alec Wilson | ||
| 2000 | Patrick Fillnow | Lauren Marie Whisenhunt | ||
| 1999 | Garrett Dong | Sunnie Harmon | ||
| 1998 | Manning Willard | Melissa Hatley | ||
| 1997 | Morgan Turner | Vardhan Vasuki | ||
| 1996 | Tai Lynch | Van Anderson | ||
| 1995 | Jennifer Simpson | Ellerbee Dargan | ||
| 1994 | Wende Ellenberg | Paul Thurmond | ||
| 1993 | Dana Davis | Robert Martin |
